the Blackthorn Orphans
  • B L O G
  • The Blackthorn Orphans: read it onsite
  • The Blackthorn Orphans TRANSLATIONS PAGE
  • Lovely R BLOG
  • PHOTOESSAYS
  • SELECTED RAVINGS: essays & opinion
  • RUBYHUE Lipstick Review
  • blackthorn ROSE REVIEW
  • KITCHEN BITCH: Recipes etc.
  • verse
  • Hostile Witness FILM REVIEW
  • ALOES & SUCCULENTS
  • Blackthorn Perfume Review
  • B I O
  • C O N T A C T

Hostile Witness Film Review: Melancholia (2011 Lars Von Trier)

19/2/2014

 
Picture
I've had dreams so like this promotional image for Melancholia that I almost have to move my head to pull my eyes away from it.  And so it was with the film itself.  So yes, I am probably guilty of excessive identification at the expense of any critical faculty.  But do you care, because I dont.  At least it's not Antichrist, jesus... reviewing that was like chasing a greasy razorback through ten fucking acres of blackberry.  With Melancholia there's less to talk about and somehow more to say; it's more than slightly omphaloskeptical, so if you're not in the mood (and I do feel you on that), you are excused without prejudice.

While less seethingly complex than Antichrist, Melancholia shares its language and conclusions.  They hold hands in the freakshow exhibit into which they were both thrust by overzealous haters.  Lars scored a (now legendary) own-goal while promoting it at Cannes with his Nazi bomb, but in doing so he was not nearly as much of a cunt as those who stood by while he was kicked out of the festival for making a bloody joke in bad taste.  Those same shameless, tutting sycophants lauded Polanski, the smirking rapist, with their next breath.  That day will live in infamy as far as I'm concerned, but onwards and upwards.

Justine (Kirsten Dunst) and Michael (Alexander Skarsgård) are hours late to their own wedding at which warring parents, horrible coworkers and the couple themselves are destined to tear semi-civil pieces from each other, the affair set in the lavish estate run by Claire (Charlotte Gainsbourg), Justine's sister, and John (Kiefer Sutherland), her husband, as a resort.  Dysfunction suffuses the reception as Justine's depression begins to lift its head, antagonizing her sister, alienating her new spouse and ushering us through the many small horrors that attend every social event when you're not particularly social yourself.  The promise of the occasion begins to unravel along with the structure of her dress; Justine's trajectory leads her to escape the festivities, fornicate with a random colleague on the golf course and reject her new husband.  During the ride insisted upon by Clair the next morning, she remarks that the strange star she had spotted the night before has disappeared, and we later learn that it has been effaced by the approach of Melancholia, a planet apparently destined to pass close to Earth in the course of its ominous orbit.  Convinced otherwise, Justine descends into lonely debilitation while Clair begins to suspect that her sister's despair has a terrible foundation.

Sounds like the bad first draft of something worse, I know, but all the best stories transcend.  Melancholia is, most of all, romantic (in the oldest, capital R sense), a dangerous thing to be for something aspiring to our cynical esteem.  Romance is an unstable chimera, part child, part adult, beaming with guileless astonishment and heavy with organic need, requiring a careful hand to balance its components.  Hollywood is hunched on the juvenile end of that seesaw, humping nonbloody adolescents and eulogizing declawed senior citizens.  Lars sits at the other end, legs dangling, staging his operas with faulty adults and real knives, taking grown-up stuff and feeding it into his sturm und drang pyre and serving romance so well that it completes its life cycle, existing as much in the crusted eye of the depressive and the tinny grey smell of denial as the luminous planet destined to smash into ours.  Who else would have the guts to tuck the chalk of office politics into bed with the cheese of galactic catastrophe?  Damn.  That's a brass neck for you.    


We should pay attention to the performances in Melancholia because they were apparently almost entirely ad-libbed, and in this case I almost believe it.  Sutherland (my former teenage husband) is pretty good, hinting at the extent of his largely squandered talent with the uneasy pitch of his vacillation, his character wobbling on an axis between panic and assurance and eventually pitching into the mealy substance of failure.  John Hurt and Charlotte Rampling are primo as the sisters' estranged parents, rattling their chains and sliding in and out of focus.  
Alexander Skarsgård is shown up as an imposter here, a big blonde bum note; luckily, (or intentionally) his shortcomings are a good fit for his character's.  His dad Stellan is much better as Justine's fork-tongued boss.  Gainsbourg is everything she should be, tender, contained, exasperated, lost in the bewildering scale of her own fate, keeping one grim hand on the rails and necessarily taking a back seat to Kirsten Dunst's dolorous prophet.  Rumour has it that this role wasn't too far to walk for her; I can believe that after nodding in unconscious agreement with the text of her malaise, her childish spite and sucking, boneless pathos.  There is always, to my eye, something horrific about Dunst's doll face, the quality of recession behind the dimples and the good skin, her skull somehow like a death's head; all darkly apposite.  Justine is charmless and unwashed, a thankless, wounded bitch; through her we are invited to examine her entanglement of reality and ailment.

The planet Melancholia is depression's hulking pole star, blotting out our rightful constellations.  Just as we know from the start that it will vaporize the silent trees and blameless horses, Justine sees it first because, like most depressives, she has always expected it.  Lars is asking if there's anything to learn from this recognition and acceptance of the inevitable.

Visually, Melancholia is drenched in unapologetic beauty.  Everything, from the sight of the opaline planet to that of Justine's unclothed form arrayed against a wooded nocturne demonstrates Von Trier's imperious command of the medium, the lavish symbolism and staging of every tableau balanced by the haunting colours of its aquatic palette.  Its daring makes it difficult to criticize.  Is it too long?  Perhaps.  Does the wedding scene double back too many times upon itself, or do Justine's wanderings require the subtle tracery of reiteration in order to illustrate the pitch of her descent?  I'm not sure.  The film is all about the images anyway, their eloquence achieved on a fairly modest budget; the end of the world sweeps across the golf course towards us in a blast of impressionistic finality which makes me think what a relief it must have been to get that scene in the can and move on. 


It's a huge relief to make it all the way through Melancholia, to be sure.  Though (and because) it spoke to me so fundamentally, I could never sit through it again.  It lodges shard-like in the succeptible and remains with you beyond your attempts to purge or rationalize, and like the knowledge of your own demise, that is both good and bad.

*   Love film?  Me too.  More Reviews Here   *



Comments are closed.

    RSS Feed

    Picture

    Independent Creativity
    Hi-Fi Introversion

    ORIGINAL CONTENT
    HONEST REVIEWS
    VELVETEEN VERBIAGE
    VISUAL LUXURY
    MORBID IDLING
    THE NATURAL WORLD
     
    ​photography  
    film
    flora  fauna  culinary
    ethnography  objet
    ​

    modest living
    ​vintage shit

    A U T H O R
    Picture
    K ✂︎ l l y
    congenital delinquent
    Human Durian
    celebrating
    glorious deviation in the land of
     the long white cloud

    -  New Zealand  -


    - T h e   B o o k -

    Picture
    T H E  
    B L A C K T H O R N
    O R P H A N S


    What is freedom, when it is
    all that remains to you?
    In exile two brothers pursue an anarchist's trajectory,  from an old world into the new, from East to West, subject always to the pleasures & horrors of an enduring flesh, to the ironies of karma & impunity. Love bears thorns, the lost return & the dead are haunted by the living. 
    ​

    E P I C   D A R K   F I C T I O N
    *   R E A D   *
    T H E
    B L A C K T H O R N 
    O R P H A N S
     O N S I T E  

    H e r e



    Picture

    Selected
    ​Ravings

    opinion essays observation private regret public 
    exaltation semicoherent speculation 

    Picture

    Photoessay​

    epic undertakings
    documented

    ​
    Picture

    Hostile Witness FilmReview

    Cruel but fair

    Picture

    RubyHue 
    ​
    Lipstick Review

    Lipstick: love it
    ​

    Picture

    Our Photography​

    we've seen worse
    ​

    Picture

    Port Chalmers​

    Dunedin, New Zealand
    ​

    Picture

    Blackthorn ​
    ​Rose Review

    Garden Hoe Wisdom
    Picture

    Verse​

    Loss, love, truth, beauty everything, everything
    ​
    Picture

    The  Lovely R's Blog​

    Likes photography  Knows a bit about it

    Picture

    We Liked This​

    Amazing things from other people
    ​

    Picture

    Cacti, Aloes
    ​&
     
    Flora​

    Our garden & general vegetal splendours
    ​

    Picture

    KitchenBitch

    Home cooking
    & raw ingredients
    ​
    Picture

    Ethnographic​

    Strange wonderful things from elsewhere
    ​

    Picture

    Jewellery
    ​

    Picture

    Tiny Little 
    Dinosaurs
    - a book for children -


    All images & text property of the authors 
    ​
    unless stated

    © us
    & original sources
    All Rights Reserved



    Picture

    Privacy Policy
    ​This is a noncommercial site.
    No ads. No shady data jacks. 
    No interest in your bizniz.

    ​We don't personally view, utilise or sell your data, apart from occasionally checking totally anonymous + super basic site view stats. We don't even know how to monetise that stuff, so don't worry.  Everyone's privacy is important to us.

    Our platform is probably harvesting your data, though, via their cookies. Look at their privacy page so you can see what they're up to.

    Please use Adblock or something similar.
    ​
    Google et al superimpose ads that we never see a penny from so fuck them.

    Picture

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013


    Picture

    Categories

    All
    A Thing Of Beauty
    Blackthorn Orphans
    Blackthorn Rose Review
    Cacti & Aloes
    Ethnographica
    Flora
    Hostile Witness Film Reviews
    Jewellery
    Kitchen Bitch
    Make Up Review
    Maximum Respect
    Perfume Reviews
    Photo Du Jour
    Photo Essay
    Places & Things: A Blackthorn Review
    Port Chalmers
    Remembering Dreams
    Roses
    Selected Ravings
    Softcore Rendition
    Sweetmeat
    Textiles
    The Lovely R
    Verse
    We Liked This

    Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.