Thought I'd round up a few frosty randoms and review them since these three MAC shades don't get too much public loving. I don't adore them myself- they were virtually all 'mixers' for me, bought to give dimension to the mattes I usually wear when I'm feeling a bit more glittery than usual. To be brutally honest, I've moved most if not all of these shades on since writing this review some time ago. So I'm just going to go ahead and admit that I'm not a frosty/lustre kind of girl and regard the latter with a bit of a jaundiced eye.
> L2 R: MAC Charismatic, Made to Order (LE), Fresh Moroccan. Photographed in warm indoor daylight.
It is 'slippy' and about 40% opaque, allowing quite a lot of natural lip colour to show through and this influences how the shade appears on you personally. Not especially buildable; the colour seems to reach a point beyond which you're just smooshing on more product rather than altering the shade. On its own, Charismatic is a comfortable, SFW kind of thing. It becomes more valuable, IMO, over a red lip pencil when you're looking for a shimmery finish.